Showdown: Schumer vs. Van Hollen

 


By Don Varyu, November 18, 2026

Sen. Chuck Schumer is under challenge from fellow Democrat Chris Van Hollen for leadership of the Democratic caucus in the U.S. Senate. It is relatively rare for this kind of challenge to be playing out in public. Van Hollen repeatedly says that the midterm elections demand change; and in this case, he vows he is the man for the job.

However…it must be said that people who demand change are frequently blinded to the possibility of change for the worse. So, would Van Hollen be better?

__

Schumer is riding something of a high following the midterms. He’s credited with personally recruiting several of the “longshot” candidates who will now serve beside him in the Senate. So, kudos on that—even though his record here was not perfect.

On the other hand, he is a wretched public speaker and has shown no capacity for developing any sort of strategy to thwart the Trump dictatorship, much less the ability to achieve results.

Van Hollen deservedly won national acclaim several years ago for traveling alone to an El Salvadorian prison to meet with constituent Kilmar Abrego Garcia, an early ICE kidnap victim who was forced into the back of a van and then flown out of the country—no appearance in court, and no chance to say goodbye to his family. To me, that grants Van Hollen at least temporary hero status.

—

But here’s the thing.

Van Hollen has now appeared in several interviews where questioners logically ask, “if you want change, what kind of change will you deliver over what Schumer is doing? What changes?”

This is a softball that should quickly be knocked over the fence. This is why key messages are formulated. But beyond a call to stop all funding for the Iran war…Van Hollen seizes up. He reverts to pablum talk about what the voters want…freedoms…how bad Trump is, etc. It feels as if he can’t recall what he’s supposed to say—or more likely, he doesn’t want to say it.

Van Hollen also says his run “is not about any one man,” But that’s preposterous; he literally is running against one single man. So why not call him out?

__

At this point, I’m moving decidedly into opinion--but I think I know the reason for his hesitation.

Chuck Schumer holds office as a Senator from New York. But it might as well be Tel Aviv. (OK, now technically Jerusalem). To say he is pro-Israel is like saying Trump is pro-Trump. Schumer has faithfully spearheaded every effort to spend more U.S. taxpayer money on Iseraeli weapons. He has bitterly fought every call for any sanction or boycott. He voted against the Obama Iran nuclear deal. He lambasted a United Nation resolution which said the forced Israeli settlements (and evictions) of Palestinians were illega, and a flagrant violation of international law.

If Israel had planted a sleeper agent inside the U.S. Senate, that spy could not be more vociferous or effective than Schumer. America is not his primary concern.

__

Van Hollen fully understands the current American condemnation of Israel’s actions in Gaza. He knows this year Gallup reported that for the first time more Americans now sympathize more with Gazans than the Israelis. And that among the nation’s Democrats, the margin is 4:1 against Israel.

What’s more, Van Hollen is among a couple dozen Senators actively demanding more investigation of Israel’s human rights violations. He is aware.

It’s unclear what blowback Van Hollen might fear. Yes, he is up for reelection in 2028, but less than 2% of American voters are Jewish. And within their ranks, there is heated division over the actions of the Netanyahu government.

--

Schumer must go, and Van Hollen can beat him—if he’s willing to speak the same truth about Isreal that most Americans feel.

Sen. Van Hollen: you were strong enough to risk your own personal safety to trael alone to visit a single constituent locked away inside a notorious El Salvadoran prison.

Certainly you can muster the same kind of courage to speak up for the constantly victimized citizens of Palestine.

# # #